Jump to content

The Warning Sirens


Ripsaw

Recommended Posts

  • Replies 43
  • Created
  • Last Reply
Heh, maybe someone should watch the firestation in Ramsey to see how many firemen come belting down the road thinking it's a shout.

 

Mission you jest. I remember before they took out the old warning sirens (about 10 years ago) they ran a test that was not well advertised. Firemen turned up at three fire stations wondering why their beepers had not gone off.

 

Hmm, 11:00 a.m. you say, might take a stroll up the street with my camera and sit on the wall outside Shoprite carpark... just in case. ;)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

What exactly are we all supposed to do on Saturday? Most of us know that it's an exercise and will simply ignore it. Those who don't will probably wonder what's going on. Either way - it's pointless. And so would be the sirens in the event of a real catastrophic event.

 

I didn't know about the siren test, and only just read this thread now. I was sitting watching TV when they went off and rather than think that it sounded like an air raid I just wondered why they were going on so long and assumed that there must be a lot of fires today so ignored them :(

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I'm unclear what is the point of this exercise. AFAIK, they're testing the sirens. That's it. But the sirens won't save anyone. It's a 1940s solution.

 

But during the blitz - people knew what to do when the sirens sounded; go to the shelters.

 

IMO - this is about creating a local political impression that something is being done. It's part of a feel - good reaction to fear. As if we can actually do anything to save us from external events.

 

So maybe it is aimed at making some people feel safer. It doesn't make us any safer. It's a game for the Civil Defence people and other interested parties. Granted the Civil Defence people provide useful support during storms, flooding and utilities outages - but they would be useless in the event of the unknown. Because the unknown is impossible to plan for.

 

This is about people pretending that significant planning exists.

 

When you have a fire drill for a building, for example, - then people know what they are supposed to do. IE - get out of the building according to the specified routes. And you aren't supposed to know that it's a drill.

 

What exactly are we all supposed to do on Saturday? Most of us know that it's an exercise and will simply ignore it. Those who don't will probably wonder what's going on. Either way - it's pointless. And so would be the sirens in the event of a real catastrophic event.

 

There is very little that we could do to save ourselves in the event of a catastrophic event which would affect us. None of us is ready or prepared to live underground for a year of more in the event of, say, a serious accident or attack at Windscale. And by the time we knew what was going on - it would be too late.

 

Pretending that we have a plan for an unknown event is a bogus starting point of view IMO. Better to spend the money lobbying internationally for the causes of terrorism and environmental decay to be addressed. And refusing business from companies based in countries whose governments do not support an international UN based perspective with respect to the causes of poverty and environmental decay.

 

And I won't be tuning into Manx Radio if the balloon ever really does go up. I don't trust them to not get the facts slightly,  but crucially, wrong. Everytime I've heard them report a story which I know something about - well they've got it wrong. Or got their words wrong. I wouldn't trust them in a crisis.

 

I was only going to quote the first few paragraphs of this post then I read on. It sums it all up quite nicely so I quoted the lot.

 

I would feel a little embarrassed and shame-faced if it was me who was 'in charge' of all this alert and what to do in an emergency carry-on.

 

But no, you can bet your bottom dollar that the sound of the sirens will have puffed up some egos no end, here on our little Island.

 

 

 

 

 

ps My son says he's going to rename his band Sound of the Sirens.

 

Edited to add:

Thanks for the cartoons Mr Ripsaw.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.

×
×
  • Create New...